Red Shield vs Black Tear
Notes, accords, longevity, sillage, seasons and community ratings, side by side.
16%scent match
Clearly different
Quick verdict
Which one should you pick?
Red Shield takes 4 of 7 categories.
Red ShieldChoose it for a powdery and iris character. Wins on ratings & consensus, value for money and versatility. Best in fall, daytime wear.
Black TearChoose it for a fruity and tobacco character. Wins on community sentiment, longevity and sillage & projection. Best in fall, evening wear.
Red Shield4/7
Black Tear3/7
- Ratings & consensus
- Red Shield
- Community sentiment
- Black Tear
- Longevity
- Black Tear
- Sillage & projection
- Black Tear
- Value for money
- Red Shield
- Versatility
- Red Shield
- Note pyramid (duration)
- Not scored
- Fragranxe ranking
- Red Shield
Head-to-head breakdown
Every category side by side, with the winner called out.
Fragrance
Red ShieldOrlov ParisBlack TearAntonio ViscontiWinner
Ratings & consensus
Average rating and ownership split4.13/ 5 · 245 votes
Have 68%Had 32%Want 0%
4.04/ 5 · 62 votes
Have 23%Had 21%Want 56%
Category winnerRed ShieldRating weighted by vote count
Community sentiment
How voters split from love to hate37%Love
42%Like
15%Ok
5%Dislike
2%Hate
172 votes
44%Love
41%Like
3%Ok
12%Dislike
0%Hate
34 votes
Category winnerBlack TearMost positive mix (25+ votes)
Longevity & sillage
0–100 community performance scores
Category winners
LongevityBlack Tear
SillageBlack Tear
Value for money
How fairly priced voters find itCategory winnerRed ShieldBest value score
Main accords
Strength of each scent family · outlined = shared by bothpowdery100%
iris92%
vanilla84%
honey77%
floral69%
sweet61%
fruity100%
tobacco92%
aromatic84%
sweet77%
green69%
woody61%
Scent match16%Clearly different · both sweet
Note pyramid (duration)
Top, heart and base, with how long each lasts when known · gold = sharedTop
HoneyAmbrette (Musk Mallow)Black PepperCedar
Heart
IrisLeatherVetiverFreesia
Base
VanillaAmberTonka BeanMusk
Top
CassisGreen AppleBlack PepperLemonBergamot
Heart
ApricotTuberoseIrisJasmineHoneyRose
Base
TobaccoPatchouliVetiverVanillaWhite Musk
InformationalShared notesHoney, Black Pepper, Iris and Vetiver. Note durations are not published for these fragrances, so this is not scored.
Seasons & time of day
Relative to each fragrance's best seasonSpring56
Summer18
Fall100
Winter89
Day100
Night–
Spring33
Summer33
Fall100
Winter67
Day60
Night100
Category winnerRed ShieldMost year-round
Who wears it
Gender appeal votesInformationalProfile onlyAudience is not scored
Ranking & credits
Fragranxe overall rank, nose and launchOverall rank#4,478
PerfumerQuentin Bisch
Launched—
Reviews41
Overall rank#9,404
PerfumerAntonio Visconti
Launched—
Reviews13
Category winnerRed ShieldHigher overall rank
In a nutshell
Description & review snapshotRed Shield is a sweet powdery leather built around honey, iris, vanilla and soft suede. On skin it can open spicy and woody, then move toward a warmer gourmand feel with amber, ambrette musk and a cherry cordial kind of sweetness mentioned by wearers. It suits people who like their leather polished, sweet and powdery …
Reviews →Black Tear opens fruity and green, with cassis, apple and citrus sharpened by black pepper. As it settles, honeyed tuberose and apricot add a plush sweetness, while tobacco, patchouli and vanilla give the dry-down a darker, fuller feel. It reads like a rich fruity gourmand with a floral heart and a tobacco-toned base.…
Reviews →InformationalRead bothTaste is personal
How we score: ratings blend public fragrance ratings with Fragranxe member votes; longevity, sillage, value and sentiment are community vote scores, and season bars are relative to each fragrance's strongest season. Categories with too little data are shown but not scored. The scent match weighs accord overlap (60%) and shared notes (40%). More in the FAQ.
Guided comparison
Ask about this matchup
Get a practical answer grounded in the fragrances currently selected.
Recent comparisons
Head-to-head activity from live history
Super CedarByredoRUNNER-UP
vs
♛
NorthMendittorosaWINNER
BohemeSegreti di LuccaRUNNER-UP
vs
♛
Soir de LuneSisleyWINNER
Orange FlowerOscar de la RentaRUNNER-UP
vs
♛
Ti AmoRoja DoveWINNER
Eau de BruxellesLibertin Louison Technique IndiscreteRUNNER-UP
vs
♛
Private ClubJeanne ArthesWINNER
Common questions
Straight answers from the data above.
Which is better, Red Shield or Black Tear?
Red Shield takes 4 of 7 categories. Red Shield is rated 4.13/5 from 245 votes; Black Tear is rated 4.04/5 from 62 votes. Choose Red Shield for a powdery and iris character. Wins on ratings & consensus, value for money and versatility. Best in fall, daytime wear. Choose Black Tear for a fruity and tobacco character. Wins on community sentiment, longevity and sillage & projection. Best in fall, evening wear.
Which lasts longer, Red Shield or Black Tear?
Black Tear lasts longest (Black Tear 80/100, Red Shield 72/100), based on community performance votes.
Which projects more, Red Shield or Black Tear?
Black Tear projects furthest (Black Tear 71/100, Red Shield 68/100), based on community performance votes.
Do Red Shield and Black Tear smell similar?
Clearly different: a 16% scent match on Fragranxe. Both share sweet accords. Common notes include Honey, Black Pepper, Iris and Vetiver.
Is Red Shield or Black Tear better for summer or winter?
For summer, Black Tear is the stronger pick. For winter, Red Shield is the stronger pick. Red Shield suits daytime wear; Black Tear suits evening wear. Based on community season votes.
What are the notes in Red Shield and Black Tear?
Red Shield has top notes of Honey, Ambrette (Musk Mallow), Black Pepper and Cedar, heart notes of Iris, Leather, Vetiver and Freesia, a base of Vanilla, Amber, Tonka Bean and Musk. Black Tear has top notes of Cassis, Green Apple, Black Pepper and Lemon, heart notes of Apricot, Tuberose, Iris and Jasmine, a base of Tobacco, Patchouli, Vetiver and Vanilla.
Popular fragrance comparisons
The matchups people have compared most on Fragranxe.
vs
Sauvage vs Bleu de Chanel
Dior · Chanel · 36 comparisons
vs
Paco Rabanne Pour Homme Rabanne for men vs Shiyaaka Shadow
Rabanne · Khadlaj Perfumes · 30 comparisons
vs
Baccarat Rouge 540 vs Khamrah
Maison Francis Kurkdjian · Lattafa Perfumes · 21 comparisons
vs
Birth of Venus vs Brioni Eau de Parfum Intense
Argos · Brioni · 17 comparisons
vs
Supremacy Not Only Intense vs Arabians Tonka
Afnan · Montale · 14 comparisons
vs
Secret De Venus Eau de Parfum vs # What Matters is Inside - Italy
Weil · Jovoy Paris · 14 comparisons