FRAGRANXE
Criminal of Love by By Kilian
988COMMUNITY BALANCE358
BY KILIANRANK #6,808 OVERALL

Criminal of Love

★★★★★★★★★★
3.861,492 votesUNISEX

Criminal of Love by By Kilian is a unisex chypre floral that centers on a deep, jammy Turkish rose. Supported by cardamom and saffron, it dries down to a rich base of tobacco, incense, and patchouli. This bold, resinous composition is perfect for formal evenings or cold-weather wear, offering a sophisticated and slightly moody profile for experienced fragrance enthusiasts.

Similar

Similar Suggestions

BETA

Performance Metrics

4,540 VOTES
LONGEVITY
72
Long
596 votes
SILLAGE
68
Strong
803 votes
LOVE / HATE
76
Liked
1,347 votes
PRICE VALUE
39
Overpriced
302 votes
RR SCORE
70
Well supported
1,492 votes
Ratings1,492
OVERALL68Well regarded4,540 votes
Open Performance Breakdown 1 TAKE

Expect excellent longevity, often exceeding eight hours on the skin. Sillage is initially strong, radiating past arm's length for about two hours, before pulling closer to the body as a sophisticated, lingering trail ideal for evening wear.

Notes Pyramid

Search these notes
TOP
MIDDLE

A dark, moody chypre floral that opens with medicinal saffron and spicy cardamom before settling into a rich, jammy Turkish rose. The experience deepens into a resinous, smoky finish defined by dry pipe tobacco, earthy patchouli, and a whisper of incense, creating a warm and complex texture on the skin.

Main Accords

13 MAPPED
Warm Spicy
Tobacco
Woody
Rose
Spicy
Patchouli
Sweet
Amber
Floral
Balsamic
Oriental
Smoky

The dominant accords of warm spice and tobacco behave as a heavy, resinous anchor. The rose facets provide a jammy lift that persists throughout, while the cedar and patchouli create a dry, woody structure that prevents the composition from feeling too sweet or overly floral.

Community Data

1,988 TOTAL VOTES

COMMUNITY SENTIMENT

OWNERSHIP STATS

GENDER APPEAL

380votes

REVIEW SENTIMENT

50%positive
Positive13
Neutral12
Negative1

When to Wear

TAP TO VOTE

SEASONS · 110 VOTES

TIME OF DAY · TAP TO VOTE

OCCASIONS · TAP TO VOTE

It looks easiest to wear in winter and spring.

Pros & Cons

Quick take before you sample

WHY PEOPLE MAY LIKE IT

+

Unparalleled dark rose composition

+

Unique, resinous tobacco backbone

+

Exceptional long-term wear on skin

+

Striking and artistic bottle design

+

Sophisticated, mysterious evening aura

+

Excellent blending of spicy and floral

+

Perfect for cold autumn and winter

+

Bold, non-gourmand unisex profile

+

High-quality, distinct note separation

+

Rewards patience in the opening

WHAT TO WATCH OUT FOR

−

Opening can be medicinal or sharp

−

Polarizing scent profile for beginners

−

Rare and difficult to source reliably

−

High cost relative to versatility

−

Not suited for warm weather days

−

Aggressive cardamom might offend some

−

Requires skin chemistry trial first

−

Potential for synthetic perception

−

Strong projection may be office-unsafe

−

Not a crowd-pleaser style fragrance

Fragranxe Review

EDITORIAL
“A Deep Dive Into the Mysterious By Kilian Criminal of Love”

The opening of Criminal of Love is nothing short of arresting. Upon the first spray, a sharp, medicinal blast of cardamom and saffron hits the senses with immediate intensity. It is a bold, challenging introduction that can feel slightly abrasive, reminiscent of iodine to some wearers. This is not a fragrance for those who prefer safe, crowd-pleasing openings, but rather for those who appreciate a narrative arc in their scents.

As the first few minutes pass, the fragrance undergoes a significant transformation. The initial medicinal edge softens, allowing a luscious, jammy Turkish rose to take center stage. This rose is not fresh or green; it is dark, honeyed, and intensely romantic, feeling like a flower pressed into a heavy velvet book. Atlas cedar enters the frame here, providing a sturdy woody backbone that keeps the rose from becoming overly sweet or cloying.

Moving into the dry-down, the composition settles into its most compelling phase. A dominant pipe-tobacco accord begins to emerge, intertwined with a smoky, resinous incense and earthy patchouli. Immortelle adds a slight, dried-herb facet that bridges the gap between the floral heart and the dark base. It behaves beautifully on skin, feeling like a warm, resinous cloak that remains dense and complex for hours after application.

In terms of performance, Criminal of Love is a solid performer. It typically lasts eight or more hours on the skin, projecting strongly for the first two hours before settling into a more intimate, sophisticated trail. It thrives in cooler weather, specifically late autumn and winter evenings, where its spicy, smoky facets can truly bloom in the cold, crisp air.

This fragrance suits an adventurous audience, regardless of gender. It demands a wearer who is comfortable with a scent that doesn't apologize for its intensity. It is an excellent fit for evening events, dinners, or nights out where a mysterious, slightly edgy scent profile is desired. It is less suitable for casual daytime wear or tight, conservative office environments.

Ultimately, Criminal of Love is a fascinating, if polarizing, work of art. While the opening may be a hurdle for some, the payoff in the heart and dry-down is undeniable. For those who love deep, tobacco-rose combinations, it is a must-sample that might just become a centerpiece in your collection.

FRAGRANXE EDITORIAL

FAQs

What is the primary scent profile of Criminal of Love?+

This is a dark, spicy chypre floral. It features a jammy Turkish rose at the heart, supported by warm, resinous notes like saffron, cardamom, and a dry, pipe-tobacco base that adds depth and mystery for autumn or winter evenings.

How does the fragrance change from opening to dry-down?+

The opening is a sharp, medicinal blast of cardamom and saffron that can feel quite intense or even iodine-like on some skin. Within twenty minutes, the initial bite subsides, letting a lush, dark Turkish rose emerge. The dry-down settles into a smoky, leathery tobacco-patchouli base that lingers for hours.

What is the typical longevity of this perfume?+

Most wearers report excellent longevity, often exceeding eight hours on skin. The combination of dense base notes like patchouli, incense, and immortelle ensures it remains present throughout a long workday or an evening out in cold, crisp air.

How strong is the projection?+

Projection starts strong, reaching past arm's length for the first two hours. It creates a bold, noticeable aura without being room-filling. As it dries down, the scent pulls closer to the body, becoming a more intimate, sophisticated trail during late-night dates.

Which season and occasion is this scent best for?+

Due to its warm, spicy, and smoky composition, this fragrance is ideal for autumn and winter. It fits formal evening events, late-night bar dates, or cozy indoor gatherings where you want a scent that feels both mysterious and comforting.

Is this a masculine or feminine scent?+

It is marketed as unisex and fits that label well. While the Turkish rose provides a traditional floral foundation, the heavy, dry tobacco and cedar notes steer it toward a slightly more masculine or edgy, adventurous lean that works for anyone.

Is this suitable for office wear?+

It can be challenging for office environments, especially during the first hour when the spicy cardamom and saffron are most aggressive. If you wear it to work, wait until the dry-down begins before heading out, or stick to one light spray to avoid overwhelming colleagues.

Does this require special storage given its age?+

As with any perfume, store it in a cool, dark place away from direct sunlight. Given that many bottles are now over a decade old, proper storage is crucial to prevent the top notes, like saffron, from turning sour or losing their vibrancy.

Are there any good alternatives or dupes?+

Finding an exact match is difficult because the composition is quite unique. Some enthusiasts point to Gucci Guilty Absolute pour Femme as a close relative, though the Kilian has a more honeyed, resinous depth compared to the cleaner Gucci profile.

Is this a good blind buy?+

Blind buying is risky due to the polarizing opening and the high price. You should sample it first to ensure the cardamom and saffron don't turn medicinal or synthetic on your specific skin chemistry before committing to a full bottle.

Rankings

Full rankings
Overall#6,808
Top Rated#18,657
Most Reviewed#6,624
Best Longevity#5,425
Best Sillage#3,770
Price Value#59,800

Wear Diary

0 COMMUNITY WEAR LOGS

Keep sprays, longevity, weather, and compliments in one practical log.

Sign in to keep private wear notes.

Compliment Signal

FROM WEAR LOGS
0TOTAL
0.00PER WEAR
0WEAR LOGS
0COMPLIMENTED

Reviews

3.9
★★★★★★★★★★
Aggregated rating

No owner review yet. You can be the first.

Dupes & Alternatives

COMMUNITY DUPESCORE

Finding a perfect alternative is a challenge. Gucci Guilty Absolute pour Femme is a common recommendation, offering a similar spirit but with less of the Kilian's jammy, honeyed rose depth. Frederic Malle Portrait of a Lady is another dark rose option, though it leans colder and more formal than this Kilian.

No User submitted dupes yet. The first useful DupeScore can come from your community.

Suggest a dupe

DUPESCORE (1–10)
COMMUNITY PULSE

Live questions about Criminal of Love

Ask one quick question and let the community weigh in while it is live.

No live pulse yet.

Trusted Sellers

Community-submitted stores that regular buyers trust, by country.

No trusted sellers added for this fragrance yet.

RetailerDiscounterDecanterMarketplace

Where to Sample

Discovery sets, official samples, and trusted decants.

No sample or decant options shared for this fragrance yet.

Official sampleDiscovery setDecant
DISCOVERY LAB · BETA

Suggestion Studio

Build a live match around the parts of Criminal of Love that matter to you.

1 Criteria2 Refine3 Results
CHOOSE AT LEAST TWO
Contribute

Add community data

Share a useful, specific detail with the community.

Community take

Add your take

Keep it clear, useful, and grounded in your own wear.

Share today’s wear

Scent of the Day · Tuesday, Oct 13

TODAY’S PICK
Criminal of LoveBy Kilian
QUICK RATING
Very good
MOOD
WEATHER
OCCASION
SPRAYS2 sprays
VISIBILITY

Write a review

For Criminal of Love by By Kilian. Every tag feeds the community data on this page.

YOUR RATING
Very good
LONGEVITY ON YOUR SKIN
SILLAGE
PRICE VALUE
WHEN DID YOU WEAR IT?
OCCASION
HOW IT READS
YOUR BOTTLE
POSTS AS @MEMBER · COUNTS TOWARD RR SCORE