
Shiloh X
Designed as a completely gender-neutral composition, Shiloh X targets wearers who appreciate vintage herbal structures and dry, textured woods over modern gourmand sugar. It thrives best during crisp autumn mornings and mild spring afternoons, offering a mature, contemplative mood for focused office work or relaxed daytime walks. The interplay of fresh citrus top notes with earthy oak moss, Virginia cedar, and resinous benzoin creates an aura of quiet confidence. Because community reception is split and production was limited to 50 ml bottles, this fragrance caters to independent niche enthusiasts who enjoy complex spicy profiles and do not mind a scent that resists current mainstream trends.
Similar Suggestions
BETAPerfumes with the nearest notes, accords and performance to Shiloh X by Hors La Monde.
Sacred FlameArgos55% scent match · 9 shared notes 4.2
Opium Francês 1977Atelier Segall & Barutti51% scent match · 9 shared notes 4.3
Acqua di Nabeel AbsoluteNabeel49% scent match · 9 shared notes 3.9
AbjarThe Spirit of Dubai49% scent match · 9 shared notes 4.5
Roses des Vents NordDorin53% scent match · 8 shared notes 3.7Matched on shared notes, accords and performance · updated Nov 17
See all 20 perfumes similar to Shiloh XFor more in-depth suggestions.
Performance Metrics
32 VOTESOpen Performance Breakdown 1 TAKE
Longevity and projection votes from the community show an unusual split across all categories. Sillage votes lean between intimate skin scent and enormous projection, while longevity votes range from under an hour to eternal wear. This spread suggests that skin chemistry and application volume dramatically alter how this fragrance performs.
Notes Pyramid
Search these notesChoose where each note belongs.
Shiloh X is built around a vivid contrast between zesty citrus top notes and a deep woody base. Grapefruit, bergamot, and tangerine open the scent with a crisp sparkle before yielding to aromatic bay leaf, cardamom, and subtle rose. The dry-down is anchored by earthy oak moss, Virginia cedar, vetiver, and resinous benzoin.
Main Accords
7 MAPPEDThe citrus accord establishes a crisp, energetic opening that gradually yields to aromatic and warm spicy facets. As the culinary herbs and cardamom soften, woody and earthy accords take control, accompanied by mossy oak moss and a dry resinous base that clings closely to the skin throughout the dry-down.
Community Data
49 TOTAL VOTESCOMMUNITY SENTIMENT
OWNERSHIP STATS
GENDER APPEAL
REVIEW SENTIMENT
When to Wear
TAP TO VOTETIME OF DAY · TAP TO VOTE
OCCASIONS · TAP TO VOTE
It looks easiest to wear in fall and spring. The vote picture leans most toward daytime.
Pros & Cons
Quick take before you sampleWHY PEOPLE MAY LIKE IT
Brisk, authentic citrus opening blending grapefruit, tangerine, and bergamot
Distinctive aromatic heart highlighting culinary bay leaf and cardamom
Classic dry-down structured around genuine oak moss and Virginia cedar
Genuinely unisex profile without sugary gourmand notes
Well suited for crisp autumn and spring daytime temperatures
Composed by recognized French perfumer Fabrice Olivieri
Clean herbal and woody balance appropriate for professional work settings
Niche appeal for collectors of discontinued 2010s chypres
WHAT TO WATCH OUT FOR
Extremely divided longevity votes ranging from very weak to eternal
Sillage feedback is unpredictable and inconsistent among wearers
Discontinued status makes sourcing full 50 ml bottles difficult
Bay leaf and oak moss notes may feel old-fashioned to modern noses
Bitter, sulfurous grapefruit edge can be polarising upon initial spray
Low total community review count leaves limited wearer consensus
Zero votes logged for summer wear, suggesting poor high-heat tolerance
Resinous and spicy base lacks the sweetness mainstream buyers often expect
Fragranxe Review
EDITORIAL“Shiloh X by Hors La Monde: Crisp Citrus Meets Earthy Woods”
The initial spray of Shiloh X by Hors La Monde delivers an invigorating, bitter-fresh rush of citrus peel. Grapefruit takes the lead with its tangy, slightly sulfurous edge, quickly joined by crisp bergamot and a juicy splash of tangerine. It does not smell like sweet candy or modern synthetic cleaner. Instead, it smells like freshly crushed fruit zest and green rind, striking an immediate tone of dry, classical elegance.
As the sharp citrus introduction begins to soften after roughly twenty minutes, the composition shifts toward a spicy, herbal heart. Cardamom lends a cool, pod-like spice, while cinnamon brings gentle warmth without sugary confection. Bay leaf introduces an aromatic, savory green facet that cuts directly through a subtle, velvety rose petal note. The dry-down gradually settles onto an earthy foundation anchored by oak moss, woody Virginia cedar, dry vetiver, and dark patchouli, cushioned quietly by amber and sweet benzoin resin.
Over the course of wear, the progression highlights several distinct aromatic transitions. The citrus accord rules the opening hour with bright energy before fading into the background. In the middle stages, the aromatic and spicy accords step forward, giving the heart a crisp, barbershop-adjacent herbal warmth. Finally, the woody, earthy, and mossy base accords dominate the skin for the remainder of the scent lifecycle, maintaining a dry, grounded forest floor character that avoids excessive amber sweetness.
Performance feedback from wearers is unusually divided. Community longevity votes are scattered across the spectrum, with single votes across very weak, weak, moderate, and eternal bands. Projection votes are similarly polarized, ranging from skin-close intimate sillage to room-filling enormous output. This variance means testing on personal skin is crucial. In terms of timing, community votes point clearly to daytime hours, particularly during the cool, transitional temperatures of fall and spring.
Shiloh X suits fragrance enthusiasts who appreciate unisex, retro-leaning chypres that prioritize herbs and woods over sweetness. Fans of bitter citrus, bay leaf, and oak moss will feel right at home here. Conversely, anyone seeking a cozy gourmand or a heavily floral bouquet should pass on this release. Those who need predictable, standardized longevity might also find the erratic performance ratings frustrating.
In the final assessment, Shiloh X remains a fascinating niche exercise in herbal and woody balance. Perfumer Fabrice Olivieri created a scent that feels distinct from mainstream designer trends, offering authentic spice and resinous woods behind an initial citrus flash. Because it is discontinued and performance varies wildly between wearers, this is strictly a sample-first fragrance for curious vintage and oriental woody collectors.
FAQs
What does Shiloh X by Hors La Monde smell like?+
Shiloh X smells like a bitter citrus opening over savory herbs and dry, earthy woods. It kicks off with a sharp blast of grapefruit, bergamot, and tangerine. The heart unfolds with spicy cardamom, cinnamon, and herbal bay leaf before settling into a traditional chypre base of oak moss, Virginia cedar, vetiver, and benzoin.
Is Shiloh X long lasting on skin?+
Community feedback on the longevity of Shiloh X is split right down the middle. Recorded votes are distributed across the spectrum, with wearers logging experiences from very weak (under one hour) to eternal (twelve hours or more). This massive spread means staying power depends heavily on your specific skin chemistry and application amount.
How strong is the projection of Shiloh X?+
Projection for Shiloh X varies widely from an intimate skin scent to enormous room presence. Community sillage votes show three votes for enormous, two for moderate, two for intimate, and one for strong. The pungent citrus and spicy bay leaf create a noticeable initial cloud before drying down closer to the body.
Is Shiloh X for men or women?+
Shiloh X is designed as a completely unisex fragrance for both men and women. The brand explicitly formulated it without a gender boundary, relying on classic elements of perfumery. Crisp citrus fruits, spicy bay leaf, vetiver, and earthy oak moss lean neither overly sweet nor strictly masculine, making it comfortable for anyone.
What season is best to wear Shiloh X?+
Shiloh X performs best during cool, transitional autumn and spring weather. Community seasonal votes put fall in the lead with three votes, followed by spring with two votes and winter with one. Summer received zero votes, indicating that its spicy cinnamon and earthy oak moss base can feel heavy in hot weather.
What occasions suit Shiloh X by Hors La Monde?+
Shiloh X is ideal for daytime professional work and relaxed casual wear. Day votes lead night votes by more than two to one in community tallies. Its brisk grapefruit opening and dry cedar-vetiver finish feel crisp, tidy, and composed, making it a reliable pick for office meetings and outdoor daytime gatherings.
Who is the perfumer behind Shiloh X?+
Shiloh X was composed by French perfumer Fabrice Olivieri. Launched in 2011 as the third creation from Hors La Monde, it followed the original Shiloh and Lady Shiloh. Olivieri crafted Shiloh X as a genderless woody-oriental fragrance that blends vibrant Mediterranean citrus top notes with a traditional spice-and-moss foundation.
How does the opening of Shiloh X compare to its dry-down?+
The opening of Shiloh X is bright and tart, whereas the dry-down is dry, mossy, and resinous. The initial minutes are dominated by zesty grapefruit, tangerine, and bergamot. As the citrus dissipates, aromatic bay leaf and cardamom emerge, eventually giving way to an earthy base of oak moss, Virginia cedar, vetiver, and benzoin.
Is Shiloh X safe to blind buy?+
Shiloh X is definitely not a safe blind buy. The fragrance holds an average rating of 3.8 out of 5 with polarized longevity and sillage ratings. Furthermore, notes like savory bay leaf and bitter oak moss can prove challenging for those accustomed to sweeter modern perfumes, making sampling essential first.
What perfumes are similar to Shiloh X by Hors La Monde?+
Shiloh X shares family DNA with the original Shiloh, while sharing woody-citrus notes with Terre d'Hermes. The original Shiloh by Michel Roudnitska emphasizes rose and patchouli more heavily, while Lady Shiloh leans powdery. Terre d'Hermes offers a comparable bitter orange and cedar-vetiver profile, though Shiloh X has much more bay leaf.
Rankings
Full rankingsWear Diary
0 COMMUNITY WEAR LOGSKeep sprays, longevity, weather, and compliments in one practical log.
Sign in to keep private wear notes.
Compliment Signal
FROM WEAR LOGSReviews
No owner review yet. You can be the first.
More from Hors La Monde
3 FRAGRANCESThe house's most-rated releases, to compare Shiloh X with its siblings.
Dupes & Alternatives
COMMUNITY DUPESCOREWithin the brand collection, the original Shiloh offers a darker, patchouli-heavy profile signed by Michel Roudnitska, whereas Lady Shiloh leans into softer powdery florals. For a wider designer alternative, Terre d'Hermes shares the bitter citrus, cedar, and vetiver combination, though it lacks the bay leaf spice of Shiloh X.
No User submitted dupes yet. The first useful DupeScore can come from your community.
Live questions about Shiloh X
Ask one quick question and let the community weigh in while it is live.
No live pulse yet.
Trusted Sellers
Community-submitted stores that regular buyers trust, by country.
No trusted sellers added for this fragrance yet.
Where to Sample
Discovery sets, official samples, and trusted decants.
No sample or decant options shared for this fragrance yet.