Skip to content
FRAGRANXE
Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy by UNTITLED
6COMMUNITY BALANCE1
UNTITLEDRANK #55,520 OVERALL

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy

★★★★★★★★★★
4.007 votesUNISEX

Designed for connoisseurs of indie perfumery who appreciate savory undertones and rustic warmth, this perfume oil bypasses conventional floral arrangements to highlight earthy gourmand facets. It pairs candied marron glace and Brazilian nut against dry vetiver and smoky tobacco, producing an evocative aroma reminiscent of autumnal woods and spiced spirits. The balance of warm spicy clove and rich cognac creates a contemplative, grounded mood ideal for crisp winter and fall days. Wearers who enjoy complex, wood-driven profiles with an artisanal edge will appreciate its slow, concentrated development on the skin. It speaks to individuals who favor cozy knitwear, fireside conversations, and distinctive, artisanal scents that stand out from modern department store releases.

Similar

Similar Suggestions

BETA

Performance Metrics

20 VOTES
LONGEVITY
80
Long
2 votes
SILLAGE
81
Enormous
4 votes
LOVE / HATE
75
Liked
7 votes
PRICE VALUE
–
No votes yet
0 votes
RR SCORE
46
Building evidence
7 votes
Ratings7
OVERALL58Building evidence20 votes
Open Performance Breakdown 1 TAKE

Community votes classify the longevity as long lasting, offering wearers between 7 and 12 hours of endurance from a single application. Sillage is voted as strong to enormous, indicating that this concentrated oil projects vigorously into the room rather than staying confined strictly to the skin.

Notes Pyramid

Search these notes
TOP 30 to 45 minutes
Not mapped
MIDDLE 3 to 4 hours
Not mapped
BASE 4 to 7 hours
Not mapped
UNCLASSIFIED NOTES

Choose where each note belongs.

Untitled No. 5 highlights an unusual blend of nutty, warm spicy, and woody accords. The scent profile centers on rich marron glace, Brazilian nut, and walnut, accented by piquant clove and cassis. Deep cognac, tobacco, vetiver, and patchouli supply a dark, resinous foundation, while honeysuckle adds a subtle floral lift to the composition.

Main Accords

6 MAPPED
Sweet
Woody
Warm Spicy
Nutty
Tobacco
Patchouli

The composition opens with dominant warm spicy and herbal accords led by clove and walnut. As it develops, the nutty and sweet accords rise forward, evoking roasted chestnuts and honeyed liquor. By the late phase, woody, tobacco, and patchouli accords take control, creating a dry, earthy, and lingering finish on the skin.

Community Data

51 TOTAL VOTES

COMMUNITY SENTIMENT

OWNERSHIP STATS

GENDER APPEAL

0votes

REVIEW SENTIMENT

0%positive
Positive0
Neutral1
Negative0

When to Wear

TAP TO VOTE

SEASONS · 4 VOTES

TIME OF DAY · TAP TO VOTE

OCCASIONS · TAP TO VOTE

It looks easiest to wear in winter and fall. The vote picture leans most toward daytime.

Pros & Cons

Quick take before you sample

WHY PEOPLE MAY LIKE IT

+

Exceptional longevity lasting between 7 and 12 hours according to community votes

+

Strong, room-filling projection uncommon for traditional perfume oils

+

Distinctive roasted nut profile featuring chestnut, walnut, and marron glace

+

Complex transitions from sharp clove to a warm woody base

+

Rich boozy depth provided by authentic cognac and tobacco notes

+

Concentrated 8 ml oil format delivers extended usage from small applications

+

Great seasonal performance during cold autumn and winter months

+

Artisanal profile crafted by independent perfumer Maria McElroy

WHAT TO WATCH OUT FOR

−

Very sharp, eye-watering clove and herbal opening noted by reviewers

−

Polarizing scent profile that requires patience during the first hour

−

Narrow seasonal versatility with little suitability for hot summer weather

−

Heavy projection may feel overwhelming in small indoor office spaces

−

Not a conventional sweet gourmand despite candied nut notes

−

Limited availability as an exclusive specialty release

−

Reviewers report a sharp masculine herbal lean that divides wearers

−

Perfume oil format lacks the quick spray dispersion of alcohol mists

Fragranxe Review

EDITORIAL
“Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy Perfume Oil Review”

The initial application of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy is assertive and unvarnished. Rather than easing in with bright citrus or sheer musks, it immediately unleashes a potent mixture of sharp clove, bitter walnut, and tart cassis. A reviewer noted that this opening is so intensely herbal and sharp that it almost makes the eyes water. Roasted nuts provide a distinctive backdrop right away, but the pungent spice holds center stage during the first twenty minutes.

As the perfume oil warms on skin, the sharp opening gradually yields to a richer, rounder core. Candied marron glace and smooth chestnut surface to introduce a mellow sweetness, joined by a golden splash of cognac. Delicate honeysuckle weaves through the midsection, preventing the blend from becoming completely dense. In the late dry-down, the scent settles into an earthy foundation of vetiver, cured tobacco leaf, and rich patchouli, evoking dried hay and rustic timber.

Over several hours, the relationship between the accords shifts noticeably. The initial warm spicy and herbal bite softens, allowing the sweet and nutty facets to become more prominent. Unlike modern gourmands that lean heavily on synthetic ethyl maltol, the sweetness here remains grounded in natural chestnut and boozy spirits. The woody base notes anchor the composition throughout, keeping the dry tobacco and earthy patchouli present until the scent finally fades.

Performance votes place this creation firmly in the long lasting category, delivering between 7 and 12 hours of reliable wear. Voters also rate the sillage as strong to enormous, meaning a small dab projects well beyond arm's length. Because of its dense character and potent projection, this scent performs best in cool autumn and winter temperatures. Community votes favor daytime wear, but its brooding warmth also makes it a solid choice for casual evening gatherings in crisp weather.

This fragrance is tailored for adventurous collectors who gravitate toward artisanal perfume oils with earthy, savory nuances. If you appreciate the interplay of roasted chestnuts, aromatic cloves, and unrefined tobacco, you will find plenty to admire here. Conversely, anyone seeking a soft floral, an airy aquatic, or a standard dessert vanilla should skip this release. The piercing spice in the opening can be polarizing for those sensitive to strong herbal elements.

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy is a bold, uncompromising blend that rewards patience. Its transition from eye-watering clove and walnut to a warm, woody tobacco base makes it a fascinating study in indie craftsmanship. While the sharp opening may deter casual shoppers, enthusiasts of rich, nutty orientals will discover a rewarding cold-weather staple.

FRAGRANXE EDITORIAL

FAQs

What does Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy smell like?+

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy smells like roasted nuts, aromatic clove, rich cognac, and earthy tobacco. It begins with a potent burst of sharp clove, cassis, and walnut before evolving into warm chestnut and sweet marron glace. Earthy patchouli and vetiver anchor the woody base, creating a rustic, savory aroma with a boozy undertone.

How long does Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy last?+

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy lasts between 7 and 12 hours based on community longevity votes. Because it is formulated as a concentrated perfume oil, it adheres firmly to the skin. The heavier base notes of tobacco, patchouli, and vetiver ensure that the scent lingers throughout an entire day.

What is the sillage and projection of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy?+

Community votes rate the projection of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy as strong to enormous. While perfume oils often sit close to the wearer, voters report that this blend radiates well beyond an arm's length, projecting a noticeable cloud of warm spice and nutty woods around the wearer.

Is Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy for men or women?+

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy is officially classified as a unisex fragrance suitable for anyone. While one reviewer found the initial sharp herbal clove and patchouli opening distinctly masculine, the development into sweet marron glace, chestnut, and honeysuckle creates a balanced, gender-neutral profile.

What season is best to wear Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy?+

Winter and fall are the best seasons to wear Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy. Community voting heavily favors cold weather, with winter receiving the majority of seasonal votes. The dense combination of roasted nuts, cognac, tobacco, and warm spices provides comforting warmth that shines in low temperatures.

How does the opening of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy compare to its dry-down?+

The opening is sharp and herbal, whereas the dry-down is warm, sweet, and woody. The initial phase hits hard with pungent walnut and eye-watering clove. Over several hours, the scent softens significantly, settling into candied marron glace, mellow cognac, earthy patchouli, and smooth tobacco leaves.

Is Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy a safe blind buy?+

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy is definitely not a safe blind buy. The sharp clove and intense herbal facet noted by wearers can be polarising. Because it avoids typical sweet vanilla gourmand structures in favor of rustic nuts and woods, sampling first is strongly recommended.

What occasions suit Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy best?+

Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy suits casual weekend wear, outdoor autumn strolls, and relaxed evenings. Community data favors daytime wear during cold months. However, its strong sillage and bold clove presence make it less ideal for formal boardrooms or cramped office environments.

How should you apply Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy perfume oil?+

Apply Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy sparingly to pulse points using a few light dabs. Because it is an 8 ml concentrated perfume oil with strong projection, a small amount on the wrists and neck generates substantial sillage without overwhelming the senses.

What fragrances are similar to Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy?+

There are no direct clones of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy, though scents like Serge Lutens Jeux de Peau share roasted nuances. While Jeux de Peau focuses on toasted bread, Untitled No. 5 highlights sharp clove, walnut, tobacco, and cognac for a much woodier, spicier edge.

Rankings

Full rankings
Overall#55,520
Top Rated—
Most Reviewed#42,522
Best Longevity#49,101
Best Sillage#60,099
Price Value#13,926

Wear Diary

0 COMMUNITY WEAR LOGS

Keep sprays, longevity, weather, and compliments in one practical log.

Sign in to keep private wear notes.

Compliment Signal

FROM WEAR LOGS
0TOTAL
0.00PER WEAR
0WEAR LOGS
0COMPLIMENTED

Reviews

4.0
★★★★★★★★★★
Aggregated rating

No owner review yet. You can be the first.

More from UNTITLED

8 FRAGRANCES
View all UNTITLED fragrances

The house's most-rated releases, to compare Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy with its siblings.

Dupes & Alternatives

COMMUNITY DUPESCORE

While Untitled No. 5 lacks direct clones, fragrance enthusiasts seeking similar cozy winter warmth often compare it to Serge Lutens Jeux de Peau, which delivers toasted grain and milky woods without the intense clove punch. Maison Margiela By the Fireplace also explores roasted chestnuts, but softens them with heavy vanilla and sweet woodsmoke rather than dry tobacco, cognac, and patchouli. Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille presents another point of reference, offering a far sweeter, creamier spiced profile that omits the bitter walnut and herbal sharpness found here.

No User submitted dupes yet. The first useful DupeScore can come from your community.

Suggest a dupe

DUPESCORE (1–10)
COMMUNITY PULSE

Live questions about Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy

Ask one quick question and let the community weigh in while it is live.

No live pulse yet.

Trusted Sellers

Community-submitted stores that regular buyers trust, by country.

No trusted sellers added for this fragrance yet.

RetailerDiscounterDecanterMarketplace

Where to Sample

Discovery sets, official samples, and trusted decants.

No sample or decant options shared for this fragrance yet.

Official sampleDiscovery setDecant
DISCOVERY LAB · BETA

Suggestion Studio

Build a live match around the parts of Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy that matter to you.

1 Criteria2 Refine3 Results
CHOOSE AT LEAST TWO
Contribute

Add community data

Share a useful, specific detail with the community.

Community take

Add your take

Keep it clear, useful, and grounded in your own wear.

Share today’s wear

Scent of the Day · Monday, Nov 16

TODAY’S PICK
Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroyUNTITLED
QUICK RATING
Very good
MOOD
WEATHER
OCCASION
SPRAYS2 sprays
VISIBILITY

Write a review

For Untitled No. 5 by Maria McElroy by UNTITLED. Every tag feeds the community data on this page.

YOUR RATING
Very good
LONGEVITY ON YOUR SKIN
SILLAGE
PRICE VALUE
WHEN DID YOU WEAR IT?
OCCASION
HOW IT READS
YOUR BOTTLE
POSTS AS @MEMBER · COUNTS TOWARD RR SCORE